Weighing In
On March 6, 2007 | 4 Comments | Uncategorized |

You know, I like to refrain, for the most part, from this kind of discourse because, really, it makes me tired. And I have So Many Other Things to think about. Honestly, I do.

But I am Sick Unto Death of this Carolina-Duke rivalry, and this is not because “my” team (that’s what one is supposed to do here, you know– claim ownership of some kind, as if fandom means ownership, or implies possession of some sort) lost Again last night to UNC, “our” second loss to “our” biggest rival in a little over a few weeks, and this time on “their” home court. No, I am not Sick Unto Death of this because “my” team lost, or because “my” team broke Tyler Hansbrough’s nose. This is not a sore loser speaking here. No, it isn’t.

No, I am Sick Unto Death because this incident only feeds a nasty persistence on the side of the UNC fans to believe that the name “Blue Devils” actually means something other than it does: the nickname of some sort of air force flying ace during one of the world wars. Yes, UNC fans like to believe that Duke is inherently wicked, that Coach K is actually some sort of demon, and that all the Duke players have shrines to Baal in their basements.

And I guess it’s exciting, isn’t it? It’s human nature, maybe, to want to believe in a Dark Side like this one.

But here’s the skinny, folks: the guy Did Not Mean to break Hansbrough’s nose.

He may have meant to be rough. He may have been going for a foul of some sort (I know so little of these things). He may have been frustrated, yea angry, at this point in the game. It’s been a bad season, and Duke was losing badly, and Heaven Only Knows that we all have a hard time in similar situations. The guy was rough, and his roughness went the Wrong Way.

Which is Really Unfortunate for him and, frankly, all of Duke, because those UNC fans in their pasty blue (and I happen to be wearing a pasty blue shirt Even As I Type) have turned this bloody and ugly accident into a giant character flaw which they will, from here on out, apply to the Entire University for as long as they have breath.

Well.

All I can say is that, for those of us dwelling in hell because of our allegiance to a deeper shade of blue, UNC’s eternal innocence, goodness, cheerfulness, magnanimity; their lack of all Irregular Playing or Deeds Done In Frustration or Anger; their generosity of spirit and purity on the basketball court and, therefore, in all manner of living; their alliance with farm animals (of an admittedly fierce variety) as opposed to princes of the air; their foregoing Ever and at Any Time any kind of behavior on or off the court that might leave them subject to criticism or even shades of doubt as to their intentions– all of this comes as sweet relief to us. All we have to worry about– ever– is a solid trouncing on the basketball court, in a game of good, clean, well-intentioned fun, whether on our court or theirs.

Isn’t it good to know, in this postmodern age, that there is such a thing as a Good Guy?

I think I’m going to move.

Comments 4
Jen F. Posted March 9, 2007 at12:33 am   Reply

Although I’m a HUGE Carolina fan (yes, HUGE), I was embarrassed at the way the Tarheel fans treated Henderson as he walked (escorted, by about six people, I guess to prevent bodily harm from the Tarheel fans) off the court. I enjoy the rivalry. I don’t know any different, being born and raised here in the land of Duke and Carolina. But I think that game was overkill for the rivalry. I don’t think Henderson meant to hurt Hansbrough. I think, like you said, he meant to foul him. But I don’t think he meant to hurt him. I don’t know why other people (Tarheel fans mostly) don’t see this, but they don’t. I love the rivalry, but I don’t love the way that a basketball game in the ACC has become the measure of personal character. Unfortunately, no one will remember that game or Henderson without thinking of the broken nose of a really good player and ejection and suspension of a really good player. I think I might move too, and be a Carolina fan from afar.

Bill Posted March 13, 2007 at3:43 am   Reply

There is an unhealthy attachment to teams, I fear. It’s as if “my” team’s winning, and the style and purity in which they win and conduct themselves, is a testament to MY personal worth. I don’t have this with Duke, but I might with the Steelers. The fact that they play (and win) with hard-nosed defense and straightforward offense, nothing fancy, no cheerleaders, no dance team… nothing but pure football as it was meant to be played, that somehow reflects my purity of character and honesty. It’s bizarre.I once was speaking to a UNC fan who took this to another level. He told me that he didn’t like coach K. I asked why… what’s not to like? He said, “well, he runs his team like a Republican and Dean Smith ran his team like a Democrat.” So now he has TWO unhealthy attachments and has managed to combine them into one neat little package… the good guys and the bad guys.No wonder political discourse is so impossible. People view political parties like sports teams.

Bill Posted March 13, 2007 at3:45 am   Reply

I can’t resist… Henderson’s hit was so bad it almost gave me a Makhtar Ndiaye or Jeff McInnis flashback.

Anonymous Posted March 18, 2007 at1:25 am   Reply

It appeared that each team was going at it very physically under the basket most of the game. Possibly it is always this way in a Duke/NC game, I don’t know. In general this “non-contact” sport is no longer anything close to non-contact.I just bet if you looked at enough game film you may in fact find a time or two when Mr Hansbrough gave a strong elbow that was more than “going for the ball”. I guess the thing that bothered me the most was that Mr Henderson had to have clearly known that he had landed a knock-out blow. And yet there was no reaching down to see if he was ok, no standing over him calling for the trainer, no hint of instant remorse. Under the circumstances it would have been appropriate… the game was over. So alas, I think my take-away from the entire incident is that I will make sure to remind my 10 and 12 year old boys to always try as hard as they can when competing in sport, to never ever give up, and lastly (and maybe most importantly) how important it is to exhibit genuine good sportsmanship at all times on the playing field and in life. Isn’t that what it is supposed to be all about?

Leave a reply

  • More news