Last Lines
On July 14, 2005 | 7 Comments | Uncategorized |

They are in the air around me today, I guess. Tworivers and I had a nice conversation this late afternoon about The Great Gatsby, and I, of course, had to quote its last line, which is one of the Best Last Lines Ever: “And so we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.”

Oh My.

I love that book, and I love that line. I memorized it I don’t know how long ago, and can’t remember doing it. I guess I just read it over and over because why wouldn’t I?

A good last line is a sigh, a gift, a segue that carries you from the book itself into your own life changed. You can’t beat a good last line.

Here’s another one, a few of them really, from Anne Tyler’s Saint Maybe: “People changed other people’s lives every day of the year. There was no call to make such a fuss about it.”

(Don’t worry, tworivers, if you haven’t read that book yet. This won’t spoil a thing.)

And from Harper Lee’s classic: “He turned out the light and went into Jem’s room. He would be there all night, and he would be there when Jem waked up in the morning.”

That line made me want to cry when I first read To Kill a Mockingbird in the 9th grade. I didn’t understand why it made me want to cry; it just did. But that’s saying something, too, isn’t it? It’s saying that just there Lee succeeded in a novel to communicate beyond language. I didn’t grasp the underlying denotation of that sentence, but it moved me anyway, like music. Now That’s Good Writing.

Tonight I finished reading E.B. White’s Charlotte’s Web to the children. It’s the third read for me since I’ve been a mother: I read it to William when he was four, to both boys when one was four and the other six, and now to all three of them at four, six, and eight. What a beautiful book that is! White makes magic of a barnyard and three generally disliked figures– a pig, a rat, and a spider. He is graphically honest about the smell of manure, the nature of selfishness, and the ugly gastronomic tendencies of his characters. But at the same time he creates a friendship that is above all things honest and deeply loving.

For the first time tonight I managed to read the last paragraph without a constricted throat and tears welling. Who do you think White was thinking of when he penned these words, or was Charlotte just as real to him as he has made her be for me?

“Wilbur never forgot Charlotte. Although he loved her children and grandchildren dearly, none of the new spiders ever quite took her place in his heart. She was in a class by herself. It is not often that someone comes along who is a true friend and a good writer. Charlotte was both.”

Comments 7
Anonymous Posted July 14, 2005 at3:52 am   Reply

Thanks for the tingles.

Rebecca Posted July 14, 2005 at12:46 pm   Reply

Happy to oblige.

Paul Marchbanks Posted July 14, 2005 at4:31 pm   Reply

You’re so right–this novel’s like poetry (as I told my wife after my last reading of it a few years ago). I’ve read fewer that were better written.Thanks for the quick stroll down memory lane (yeah, I suppose the pun’s intended). Haven’t been able to read much American fiction since my first year in grad school, but fondly remember teaching Gatsby a few years ago, as well as working back in undergrad on the self-deception and memory manipulation of various American literary figures (including Gatsby). An interesting question, to what degree we should value the past. T. S. Eliot and Faulkner would say there’s little else to know, but then, we’re sure not supposed to let *live* in it (anyone familiar with the enormous photo gallery I’ve created for our family will hopefully laugh at my hypocrisy here). Fitzgerald’s metaphor sure is the right one, isn’t it? It’s so much easier to release the oars and get swept back into what it’s so easy to romanticize.Some good readin’ you got goin’ there.

Paul M. Posted July 14, 2005 at4:32 pm   Reply

Oh, and though I’ve never read Charlotte’s Web, I did play the role of Templeton in a community production of the play once upon a time!More good memories you’re provoking!

Anonymous Posted July 16, 2005 at2:43 pm   Reply

Paul M, you MUST read Charlotte’s Web! I’m not sure how many times I’ve read it, Rebecca, but I know I’ve not read it to Madelyn, so it’s time for another go at getting through the last paragraph without tears!

Rebecca Posted July 18, 2005 at2:26 am   Reply

Paul,Yes, Fitzgerald’s Gatsby is a *perfect* book. I’ve had the pleasure of teaching it a number of times. There’s nothing like teaching something for learning it.I am fascinated by memory, too, and am working heavily with it in my creative *project*. We looked at memory a bit in a modernist course I took; I really enjoyed Proust’s treatment of memory in Swann’s Way, and hope to look at that more in depth.But I don’t take Fitzgerald’s last line as a willing surrender to memory, preferring it to the present or even the future. To me, it reads that memory is the current — we are naturally drawn backward, even though we set our boats “against the current”; almost trying to avoid it?Help me if I’ve got that wrong.And– for heaven’s sake!– read Charlotte’s Web!!!!

Paul Marchbanks Posted July 18, 2005 at12:58 pm   Reply

Oh, no–I totally agree with your reading of those lines: memory as current we usually row against, though sometimes it’s far easier to let it carry us back into the rosy haze of the recreated not-now.

Leave a reply

  • More news